Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Ohiosally

Is it slander to report information to the police?

5 posts in this topic

I reported information to the police about someone that I was told had many guns. I then also called back the police and said I wasn't sure if this is true or not, and they should not listen to me (retracted what I said) and that this was told to me by somebody else (and I gave the name) No damages were done to this person, and no investigation ensued. Now this person is suing me for defamation. Aren't there laws protecting when reporting to police officials? I never did this with any malice but for protection because I had an order of protection against this person, and it had on the TOP, that guns should be confiscated. And three guns were, but not as I originally told the police which was that he had loads and loads of guns. What laws can protect me or what source can I find this online? The person filing the suit is an ohio resident and the defamation suit was filed in Ohio, I called the police in Ohio over the phone when I was in California. I am not a resident of Ohio. I have only been there twice to visit a friend.Thank you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"Now this person is suing me for defamation."

If you've been sued, unless it's a small claims court-level matter, you definitely talk with an attorney.

Even if the police HAD conducted an investigation, what you describe isn't "slander" or "defamation".

 

"Aren't there laws protecting when reporting to police officials?"

This isn't a relevant aspect of the situation.

 

"What laws can protect me ..."

The truth and, in this case, the fact that the dumbass should have sued you in California.  :)

"... or what source can I find this online?"

Please do not limit your research to "online" (I'll never understand why folks seem to insist that this is the only way to conduct research/gather information).

 

What you can do is research how to file an answer in this Ohio court after you have been served with a lawsuit.  Personally, I'd cite not being an Ohio resident and that the court has no jurisdiction over me and that I've no business there, and I'd also toss in that the dolt was not harmed by your call and in fact I'd mention the protective order.  If you don't figure how to navigate this (and it's not something someone will walk you through online), I suggest you contact an Ohio attorney.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I reported information to the police about someone that I was told had many guns. I then also called back the police and said I wasn't sure if this is true or not, and they should not listen to me (retracted what I said) and that this was told to me by somebody else (and I gave the name)

 

Just as an FYI, people sometimes retract things that are true because they regret having reported them.  The police know this.

 

 

 

No damages were done to this person, and no investigation ensued. Now this person is suing me for defamation.

 

Something must have happened.  Otherwise the person wouldn't have known to sue you about it.  Right?

 

 

 

Aren't there laws protecting when reporting to police officials?

 

Yes, but they're not absolute.

 

 

 

I never did this with any malice but for protection because I had an order of protection against this person, and it had on the TOP, that guns should be confiscated. And three guns were, but not as I originally told the police which was that he had loads and loads of guns. . . . The person filing the suit is an ohio resident and the defamation suit was filed in Ohio, I called the police in Ohio over the phone when I was in California. I am not a resident of Ohio.

 

How is it that you obtained an order of protection against this person who lives 2,000 or so miles away from you, and why did you believe you needed to make a report about someone so far away having guns?

 

 

 

Even if the police HAD conducted an investigation, what you describe isn't "slander" or "defamation".

 

I disagree.  That the person in question had the guns is a statement of fact that is of and concerning this person.  It is essentially an allegation that the person committed a crime, which is unquestionably defamatory.  The best defenses likely will be the alleged lack of damages and the possibility that the report was privileged.

 

 

 

What you can do is research how to file an answer in this Ohio court after you have been served with a lawsuit.  Personally, I'd cite not being an Ohio resident and that the court has no jurisdiction over me and that I've no business there

 

There is no jurisdictional issue here.  The poster availed him/herself of Ohio law to make a complaint to law enforcement in Ohio regarding an Ohio resident.  This is textbook Calder v. Jones.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 I had an order of protection against this person, and it had on the TOP, that guns should be confiscated.

 

Something doesn't make sense here.

 

Why did you have an order of protection? Ex boyfriend, ex husband. If you live in CA and he is in OH why would you even be concerned about his guns.

 

As for the lawsuit I'll bet he's counting on you not responding properly so he can get a default judgment against you and make your life miserable in exchange for you ratting him out about the guns.

 

Hire yourself a lawyer.

 

By the way, reporting that he had three guns would have been a defensible statement of fact, reporting that he had loads and loads of guns could rise to a level of malicious defamation.

 

Recanting your report doesn't count. You made the report and there were consequences. He's got the right to sue you for it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0